Evolving on Two Fronts: Oak Species and Syngameons

Andrew L. Hipp

Published May 2026 in International Oaks No. 37: 97–106

Abstract

William ‘Bill’ Burger wrote in 1975, “I believe that the classical species-concept in Quercus defines a very real population system and that it evolves on two fronts. The first is that of continuing to adapt to a niche that differs slightly from its close relations. The second is in sharing the broader evolutionary advances of these same close relations that together comprise the genetically isolated biological species.” Burger’s view of oak species reflected morphological study going back at least to 1947, but since Burger’s time, ecological and genomic data have accrued to further support his hypothesis: oak species are distinctive ecologically, morphologically, and genomically, but interspecific gene flow moves alleles (gene copies) between species. This movement of alleles between species is called introgression. Introgression increases genetic variation within species and shuffles alleles into new ecological contexts, where they may shape the evolution of the species they enter. Thus natural selection working on a single population does so by grabbing hold of innovations (alleles) that evolved in the suite of interbreeding species that constitute an oak syngameon. In this essay, I discuss Bill Burger’s species concept and ask how it aligns with what we know about oak species today.

Keywords

adaptation, genomics, hybridization, introgression, species concepts

References

Abadie, P., G. Roussel, B. Dencausse, C. Bonnet, E. Bertocchi, J.-M. Louvet, A. Kremer, and P. Garnier-Géré. 2012. Strength, diversity and plasticity of postmating reproductive barriers between two hybridizing oak species (Quercus robur L. and Quercus petraea (Matt.) Liebl.). Journal of Evolutionary Biology 25: 157-173.

Anderson, E. 1949. Introgressive Hybridization. John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York.

Anderson, E., and L. Hubricht. 1938. Hybridization in Tradescantia. III. The Evidence for Introgressive Hybridization. American Journal of Botany 25: 396-402.

Barraclough, T.G. 2024. Does selection favour the maintenance of porous species boundaries? Journal of Evolutionary Biology 37: 616-627.

Boecklen, W.J. 2017. Topology of syngameons. Ecology and Evolution 7: 10486-10491.

Bourdeau, P. 1954. Oak Seedling Ecology Determining Segregation of Species in Piedmont Oak-Hickory Forests. Ecological Monographs 24: 297-320.

Buck, R., and L. Flores-Rentería. 2022. The Syngameon Enigma. Plants 11: 895.

Burger, W.C. 1959. A study of Quercus bicolor, Quercus macrocarpa, and their presumed hybrids in the Cayuga Lake basin, New York. M.S. thesis, Cornell University, New York.

Burger, W.C. 1975. The species concept in Quercus. Taxon 24: 45-50.

Cannon, C.H., and M.T. Lerdau. 2019. Demography and destiny: The syngameon in hyperdiverse systems. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 116:8105-8105.

Cannon, C.H., and R.J. Petit. 2020. The oak syngameon: more than the sum of its parts. New Phytologist 226: 978-983.

Cavender-Bares, J. 2019. Diversification, adaptation, and community assembly of the American oaks (Quercus), a model clade for integrating ecology and evolution. New Phytologist 221: 669-692.

Cavender-Bares, J. 2025. Oak Origins and the Pharaoh’s Dance: whither the syngameon concept? Evolution: qpaf195.

Cavender-Bares, J., D.D. Ackerly, D.A. Baum, and F.A. Bazzaz. 2004. Phylogenetic Overdispersion in Floridian Oak Communities. The American Naturalist 163: 823-843.

Cavender-Bares, J., S. Kothari, J.E. Meireles, M.A. Kaproth, P.S. Manos, and A.L. Hipp. 2018. The role of diversification in community assembly of the oaks (Quercus L.) across the continental U.S. American Journal of Botany 105: 565-586.

Fallon, B., and J. Cavender-Bares. 2018. Leaf-level trade-offs between drought avoidance and desiccation recovery drive elevation stratification in arid oaks. Ecosphere 9(3): e02149.

Fontes, C.G., J.E. Meireles, A.L. Hipp, and J. Cavender-Bares. 2025. Adaptive Evolution of Freezing Tolerance in Oaks Is Key to Their Dominance in North America. Ecology Letters 28: e70084.

Fu, R., Y. Zhu, Y. Liu, Y. Feng, R.-S. Lu, Y. Li, ...and J. Chen. 2022. Genome-wide analyses of introgression between two sympatric Asian oak species. Nature Ecology & Evolution 6: 924-935.

Grant, V. 1971. Plant Speciation. First Edition. Columbia University Press, New York.

Guo, M., N. Hu, G. Feng, L. Wang, D. Gambhir, A. Khanal, B. Hyden, L.B. Smart, B.J. Sanderson, and M.S. Olson. 2025. Divergence, hybridization, and diversification in an eastern North American willow syngameon. New Phytologist 248: 1044-1057.

Hardin, J.W. 1975. Hybridization and introgression in Quercus alba. Journal of the Arnold Arboretum 56: 336-363. Hipp, A.L. 2015. Should hybridization make us skeptical of the oak phylogeny? International Oaks 26: 9-18.

Hipp, A.L. 2024. Oak Origins: From Acorns to Species and the Tree of Life. University of Chicago Press, Chicago.

Kaproth, M.A., B.W. Fredericksen, A. González-Rodríguez, A.L. Hipp, and J. Cavender-Bares. 2023. Drought response strategies are coupled with leaf habit in 35 evergreen and deciduous oak (Quercus) species across a climatic gradient in the Americas. New Phytologist 239: 888-904.

Klein, E.K., L. Lagache-Navarro, and R.J. Petit. 2017. Demographic and spatial determinants of hybridization rate. Journal of Ecology 105: 29-38.

Kremer, A., and A.L. Hipp. 2020. Oaks: an evolutionary success story. New Phytologist 226: 987-1011.

Lepais, O., R. Petit, E. Guichoux, J. Lavabre, F. Alberto, A. Kremer, and S. Gerber. 2009. Species relative abundance and direction of introgression in oaks. Molecular Ecology 18: 2228-2242.

Lepais, O., G. Roussel, F. Hubert, A. Kremer, and S. Gerber. 2013. Strength and variability of postmating reproductive isolating barriers between four European white oak species. Tree Genetics & Genomes 9: 841-853.

Leroy, T., J.-M. Louvet, C. Lalanne, G. Le Provost, K. Labadie, J.-M. Aury, ...and A. Kremer. 2020. Adaptive introgression as a driver of local adaptation to climate in European white oaks. New Phytologist 226:1171-1182.

Liang, Y.-Y., H. Liu, Q.-Q. Lin, Y. Shi, B.-F. Zhou, J.-S. Wang, …and B. Wang. 2025. Pan-Genome Analysis Reveals Local Adaptation to Climate Driven by Introgression in Oak Species. Molecular Biology and Evolution 42: msaf088.

Mallet, J. 1995. A species definition for the modern synthesis. Trends in Ecology & Evolution 10: 294-299.

McCormack, M.L., M.A. Kaproth, J. Cavender-Bares, E. Carlson, A.L. Hipp, Y. Han, and P.G. Kennedy. 2021. Climate and phylogenetic history structure morphological and architectural trait variation among fine-root orders. New Phytologist 228:1824-1834.

Muller, C.H. 1952. Ecological Control of Hybridization in Quercus: a Factor in the Mechanism of Evolution. Evolution 6: 147-161.

Nagamitsu, T., K. Uchiyama, A. Izuno, H. Shimizu, and A. Nakanishi. 2020. Environment-dependent introgression from Quercus dentata to a coastal ecotype of Q. mongolica var. crispula in northern Japan. New Phytologist 226:1018-1028.

O’Donnell, S.T., S.T. Fitz-Gibbon, and V.L. Sork. 2021. Ancient Introgression Between Distantly Related White Oaks (Quercus sect. Quercus) Shows Evidence of Climate-Associated Asymmetric Gene Exchange. Journal of Heredity 112:663-670.

Palmer, E.J. 1948. Hybrid oaks of North America. Journal of the Arnold Arboretum 29:1-48.

Parker, J.B., S. Hoban, L.M. Thompson, and S.E. Schlarbaum. 2025. Evaluating the Central-Marginal Hypothesis: Introgression and Genetic Variation at the Trailing Edge of Quercus bicolor. Molecular Ecology n/a: e70185.

Petit, R.J., C. Bodénès, A. Ducousso, G. Roussel, and A. Kremer. 2004. Hybridization as a mechanism of invasion in oaks. New Phytologist 161: 151-164.

Ramírez-Valiente, J.A., R. López, A.L. Hipp, and I. Aranda. 2020. Correlated evolution of morphology, gas exchange, growth rates and hydraulics as a response to precipitation and temperature regimes in oaks (Quercus). New Phytologist 227: 794-809.

Reutimann, O., B. Dauphin, A. Baltensweiler, F. Gugerli, A. Kremer, and C. Rellstab. 2023. Abiotic factors predict taxonomic composition and genetic admixture in populations of hybridizing white oak species (Quercus sect. Quercus) on regional scale. Tree Genetics & Genomes 19: 22.

Ribicoff, G., M. Garner, K. Pham, K.N. Althaus, J. Cavender-Bares, A.A. Crowl, …and A.L. Hipp. 2025. Introgression, Phylogeography, and Genomic Species Cohesion in the Eastern North American White Oak Syngameon. Molecular Ecology n/a: e17822.

Rieseberg, L.H., T.E. Wood, and E.J. Baack. 2006. The nature of plant species. Nature 440:524-527.

Schwilk, D.W., M.S. Gaetani, and H.M. Poulos. 2013. Oak Bark Allometry and Fire Survival Strategies in the Chihuahuan Desert Sky Islands, Texas, USA. PLOS ONE 8: e79285.

Spellenberg, R., J.R. Bacon, and M.S. González Elizondo. 1998. Los encinos (Quercus, Fagaceae) en un transecto sobre la Sierra Madre Occidentale. Boletín del Instituto de Botánica de la Universidad de Guadalajara 5: 357-387.

Stebbins, G.L. 1950. Variation and Evolution in Plants. Columbia University Press, New York.

Stebbins, G.L., E.G. Matzke, and C. Epling. 1947. Hybridization in a Population of Quercus marilandica and Quercus ilicifolia.

Evolution 1:79-88.

Swenson, N.G., J.M. Fair, and J. Heikoop. 2008. Water Stress and Hybridization between Quercus gambelii and Quercus grisea. Western North American Naturalist 68:498-507.

Trelease, W. 1924. The American Oaks. Memoirs of the National Academy of Sciences 20:1-255. Van Valen, L. 1976. Ecological species, multispecies, and oaks. Taxon 25:233-239.

Whittaker, R.H. 1969. Evolution of diversity in plant communities. In: Diversity and stability in ecological systems. Brookhaven Symposium in Biology 22:178-195.

Whittemore, A.T. 1993. Species concepts: a reply to Ernst Mayr. Taxon 42:573-583.

Whittemore, A.T., and R.E. Miller. 2023. Dynamic properties of the pinyon pine syngameon. New Phytologist 237:1943-1945. Wiegand, K.M. 1935. A Taxonomist’s Experience with Hybrids in the Wild. Science 81:161-166.

Wu, Y., A.G. Linan, S. Hoban, A.L. Hipp, and R.E. Ricklefs. 2024. Divergent ecological selection maintains species boundaries despite gene flow in a rare endemic tree, Quercus acerifolia (maple-leaf oak). Journal of Heredity 115:575-587.

Zhou, B.-F., S. Yuan, A.A. Crowl, Y.-Y. Liang, Y. Shi, X.-Y. Chen, ...and B. Wang. 2022. Phylogenomic analyses highlight innovation and introgression in the continental radiations of Fagaceae across the Northern Hemisphere. Nature Communications 13:1320.

Zimmermann, F., O. Reutimann, A. Baltensweiler, L. Walthert, J.K. Olofsson, and C. Rellstab. 2025. Fine-Scale Variation in Soil Properties Promotes Local Taxonomic Diversity of Hybridizing Oak Species (Quercus spp.). Evolutionary Applications 18:e70076.